- Primary Subject: 3D Games That Would Be Better in 2D
- Key Update: Following a wave of high-profile, over-budget 3D releases in early 2026, players are turning back to tight, linear gameplay mechanics, sparking an editorial shift that re-evaluates historic and modern 3D titles.
- Status: Confirmed
- Last Verified: May 18, 2026
- Quick Answer: Transitioning to 3D often compromises a franchise's fundamental pacing, visual polish, and focused level design, making a flat 2D perspective structurally superior for certain games.
In the past, video games were almost exclusively played within the 2D realm. That means the only directions you could go were up, down, left, and right, and that you had a fixed flat perspective from beginning to end. It was simple, and it worked, with many developers creating masterpieces through 2D.
Years and decades later, the majority of video games shifted and becoma three-dimensional, meaning they now had a whole sandbox for players to explore no longer bound to a single perspective. The new direction certainly yielded incredible results, with early examples such as The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time redifining the industry, all the way to Elden Ring, and more recent names like Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 and Pragmata.
However, not all 3D games are exceptional, as some failed to meet expectations and became utter disappointments. In fact, there are instances where such video games would be much better off in 2D instead, as their flaws would have either been greatly diminished or removed completely if they were. As for which ones would be the perfect examples, here are some names that come to mind.
1. Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)
Many who owned an Xbox 360 or a PlayStation 3 will likely remember the mess that was Sonic the Hedgehog 2006. When this video game was released, many who chose to play it were met with bugs that broke the game, numerous unnecessary and terribly long loading scenes, and a realistic art style that felt out of place for a game with anthropomorphic animal heroes and villains.
Those issues made for a tedious and frustrating experience, and they likely could have been prevented if the game had been designed in 2D rather than in 3D. If it were, it likely would have run much smoother, and it would have had a much better visual design and gameplay. Also, the different areas Sonic and the gang travel to could have been more condensed, allowing for a much more linear but more fun journey.
2. Metroid Prime 4: Beyond
While it wouldn't be right to make Metroid Prime 4: Beyond a 2D title, given that the series is known for being in 3D, I believe that this entry would have greatly benefited from it. One of the reasons many found it disappointing was due to its linearity, as it focused so much on the shooter aspect that it felt like the team behind the game's development didn't put in as much effort on the exploration.
If it had gone for a 2D approach instead, there would likely have been a much better atmosphere between areas and additional pathways that would have truly made it feel like there were more than one way to reach the desired destination. It also would have allowed the player to feel more isolated with the limited perspective, which the 4th game should have done in the first place.
3. Pokemon Sword and Shield
Some might say that Scarlet and Violet should have been here instead, but at least the 3D aspect actually helped enhance its more open-ended gameplay. Sword and Shield, on the other hand, does not have that benefit, and it would have been much better off in 2D.
Both video games had problems when it came to their visuals, as many pointed out the low quality of different models and the attack animations performed by the Pokemon themselves. If it were in 2D instead, the pixel art style would have drastically improved the overall look of everything. It would also have allowed for an easier time in creating more unique attack animations, giving the game and its Pokemon the personality it should have had.
4. Mega Man X7
Of all the transitions from 2D to 3D, Mega Man X7 is probably one of the most notorious for being the game that made its series one of the worst examples. As for how it did so, it was due to its overall terrible level design, as the majority of enemies and obstacles could be ignored and run through.
This means there was barely any challenge, and when players did reach the boss fights, they were unbalanced to the point that they weren't fun to fight. If the game were in 3D, the stages and enemy placements would likely have been handled much better, and major battles would have been more exciting, rather than the tedious and drawn-out experiences they are now.
5. Final Fantasy 7
The original Final Fantasy 7 is still lauded as one of the classics, perhaps even considered as one of the best video games of all time. While it did offer a spectacular journey, it would have had an even better one if the game had gone with 2D instead of 3D.
The problem with the original Final Fantasy 7 is that the use of 3D polygons made it feel so dated. Some of the characters and even the locations themselves look awful or are a chore to go through because of it, which is a shame, as they would have looked more gorgeous in 2D. Again, nothing was wrong with the game, but it could have been so much more with a simple change in perspective.
While there are other examples out there that would be perfect for this list, I believe these five top them all. Of the many that you've played, stop to consider what you think would have been better off in 2D instead of 3D, as you might find yourself in surprise with the names you might be able to think of.
For more like this, stick with us here at Gfinityesports.com, the best website for gaming features and opinions.